“The Bay,” the fifth track on Orange Earth, features vocals from Mulherin. In it, Mulherin is speaking to his love interest with whom he is struggling to move past. It was produced and arranged by Joao Gonzalez and written by Marshall and Parker Mulherin.
Hey, hey, hey
Leaving you alone is too hard (Hard, hard)
I just never know where to start with you
I'm not used to leaving someone brokenhearted
That might be what really makes this hardest (Hardest)
I've never been with anyone this long
If I did it, I'd really miss you
So at this moment
Baby, tell me, what should I do? (Do)
[Instrumental Break]
Nothing that I do can make this better
Everything you said, it happened, no
You could see the future with your telescope eyes
I can't see that far, that's why we fell apart, oh no
I'm not used to leaving someone brokenhearted
That might be what really makes this hardest (Hardest)
I've never been with anyone this long
If I did it, I'd really miss you (You)
If I told you I was done
Yes, just because I wasn't ready
And I apologize for everything