Samantha

[Verse 1]
I was my best self with you
You said you had never seen eyes quite so blue
Got lost in them like I wanted you to
And I was gentler than I ever knew

You picked me up in a borrowed van
At the coffee shop I held your hand
And I don't think I'll ever understand
How you could change your mind like that
How you could take it all back

[Chorus]
Oh, Samantha
Why'd you have to leave?
(Why'd you have to leave?)
Oh, Samantha
Oh, why can't you love me
Like you said you did?
Oh, nothing that's true is

[Verse 2]
We watched the crows by the shore
You always left me wanting more
Did you give up or just get bored?
Now all your things are in a box by the door
And I'm wondering what else you could be looking for

[Chorus]
Oh, Samantha
Why'd you have to leave?
(Why'd you have to leave?)
Oh, Samantha
Oh, why can't you love me
Like you said you did?
Oh, nothing that's true is

Nothing that's true is
Nothing that's true is
Nothing that's true is

[Bridge]
I've been giving all of me and now I'm hollow
That's a goddamn hard pill to swallow
(Nothing that's true is)
(Nothing that's true is)
All my friends say loyalty is my best trait
(Nothing that's true is)
(Nothing that's true is)
With you it was my mistake
(Nothing that's true is)
(Nothing that's true is)
I've been giving all of me and now I'm hollow
(Nothing that's true is)
(Nothing that's true is)
That's a goddamn hard pill to swallow
(Nothing that's true is)
(Nothing that's true is)
All my friends say loyalty is my best trait
(Nothing that's true is)
(Nothing that's true is)
With you it was my mistake
(Nothing that's true is)
(Nothing that's true is)

[Outro]
Oh, Samantha
I'd have done anything for you
In the end moving on was all I could do