“Prom or Hell?” is a non-album track in Heathers: The Musical. It is sung after “Our Love is God”, and shows Veronica reflecting on her relationship with J.D. and how the people that he killed were bad people, but they were still teenagers and could have changed.
[VERONICA]
Dear diary:
I'm going steady
Mostly he's awesome
If a bit too “rock and roll”
Lately he's bumped off
Three of my classmates
God, have mercy on my soul
They were just seventeen
They still had room to grow
They could have turned out good
And now we'll never know
Heathers-the-musical-ensemble released Prom or Hell? on Mon Jun 09 2014.