Old Spice (Eric #1)

You carved my heart out at seventeen
Band camp and mix tapes and movie screens
Wrong coast and you liked the wrong team
No prince, but you charmed me, you charmed me

Caught making out in the parking lot
Toothless, ripped dress at junior prom
Thought I would die when you broke it off
You carved my heart out

The smell of Old Spice still gets me wet
Do you ever feel that shred of regret?

Every time I think of you
I′m staring straight into the sun
But I can't take
My eyes away
Every time I think of you
I feel the barrel of a gun
But it won′t take
The pain away that you
Put me through

You carved my heart out at twenty-three
Wish I ignored you on Bleecker Street
When you said let's catch up and get a drink
But your blue eyes disarmed me, disarmed me

Jules bet that romance is what you meant
Thought we would kiss til you turned your head
You said "I just want to be your friend"
You carved my heart out

The smell of Old Spice still gets me wet
Do you ever feel that shred of regret?

Every time I think of you
I'm staring straight into the sun
But I can′t take
My eyes away
Every time I think of you
I feel the barrel of a gun
But it won′t take
The pain away that you
Put me through
That you
Put me through

I wish I could put the last nail in your coffin
But I'd bury the girl
Who believed in the fantasy
Of fairytale endings, true love, and devotion
And how could I die for you if you′re dead to me?

Every time I think of you
I'm staring straight into the sun
But I can′t take
My eyes away
Every time I think of you
I feel the barrel of a gun
But it won't take
The pain away that you
Put me through
That you
Put me through
Every time
Every time