[Verse 1]
Maybe I
Overstayed
That summer day
Blood shot eyes
Crying all over your sunburnt shoulders
Held on tight
To every bit
Of your affection
When you were mine
What a time
[Pre-Chorus]
Oh
I was in heaven
And never looking down
I wasn't ready, no
[Chorus]
No matter what I do
It's never gonna be enough
I can never fall in love
With someone new
Praying never helped me much
Running out of faith
I had it then I lost it
Call that shit agnostic
Baby, what'd you do?
Baby, what'd you do?
[Verse 2]
Devoted til you cut me open
Now I can't feel the simplest emotion
Wish I had something to believe in
Just another lonely weekend
The way you touched me felt so holy
I can't let nobody hold me
Wish I had something to believe in
[Chorus]
No matter what I do
It's never gonna be enough
I can never fall in love
With someone new
Praying never helped me much
Running out of faith
I had it then I lost it
Call that shit agnostic
Baby, what'd you do?
[Verse 3]
I've heard the stories of
A different kind of love
Maybe it wasn't us
And maybe there's another way
And when I'm in their arms
You'll still be pulling me away
[Chorus]
No matter what I do
It's never gonna be enough
I can never fall in love
With someone new
Praying never helped me much
Running out of faith
I had it then I lost it
Call that shit agnostic
Baby, what'd you do?
(Baby, what'd you do?)
[Chorus]
No matter what I do
It's never gonna be enough
I can never fall in love
With someone new
Praying never helped me much
Running out of faith
I had it then I lost it
Call that shit agnostic
Baby, what'd you do?
[Outro]
Baby, what'd you do?
Agnostic was written by Daya & Caroline Sans & Chelsea Balan.
Agnostic was produced by Caroline Sans.
Daya released an image of her legs covered in lace, as well as a short TikTok video before announcing the single on July 31, 2025.
One of my favorite songs I’ve written, “Agnostic,” comes out next week!! I wrote this song 2 summers ago during a New York trip, where I met Caroline Sans, the producer, at her apartment for the first time. We shared a lot of similar references off the bat, and she had prepped the starting points of...